The landscape of Mergers & Acquisitions (M&A) is undergoing a significant transformation each year. Activist investors, once viewed as peripheral players, have emerged as influential forces capable of reshaping deal dynamics and influencing corporate strategy. M&A activity is no longer solely about maximizing short-term shareholder returns through quick fixes. Today’s investors are increasingly looking for deals that create sustainable value over the long term. This focus on long-term value encompasses factors like a company’s innovation potential, brand reputation, and ability to adapt to changing market conditions. Companies that prioritize these aspects are not only more attractive to investors but are also better positioned to navigate the complexities of the modern business environment.

Who are Activist Investors in M&A?

Activist investors are strategic stakeholders who acquire significant shareholdings in companies with the express purpose of influencing management and direction, particularly regarding M&A activity. Their primary objective is to unlock shareholder value through a variety of means, including advocating for mergers, acquisitions, divestitures, or even opposing deals deemed unfavorable. They leverage their ownership stake to exert pressure on leadership, often resorting to public campaigns to champion their preferred strategies.

Let’s explore a case study on the influence of activist investors and how they created a lasting impact.

Engine No. 1: Investor Activists with an ESG edge

Engine No. 1, a relatively small activist investor group, disrupted the M&A landscape in 2021 by securing board seats at ExxonMobil, a global energy giant. Their audacious campaign transcended the typical focus on maximizing shareholder returns. Engine No. 1 specifically advocated for ExxonMobil to prioritize climate change mitigation strategies, demonstrating the growing influence of activist investors with environmental, social, and governance (ESG) agendas.

This successful campaign underscores a significant shift within the activist investor landscape. Engine No. 1’s win highlights the ability of such groups to exert pressure on companies to adopt sustainable practices, potentially impacting future M&A strategies. Companies engaged in M&A activity may now need to consider not only traditional financial metrics, but also environmental and social responsibility factors when evaluating potential deals. The long-term ramifications of Engine No. 1’s involvement with ExxonMobil remain to be fully understood. However, their success serves as a clear indicator that ESG considerations are becoming a critical component of the activist investor era, potentially shaping the future of M&A transactions.

Activist Investors: Identifying targets and advocating for change

Activist investors are potential targets within the M&A landscape through various approaches. These approaches involve a blend of financial analysis, industry benchmarking, and corporate governance scrutiny:

• Financial analysis: Activist investors analyze valuation metrics like Price-to-Earnings (P/E) ratios and free cash flow to pinpoint companies trading below their intrinsic value. They seek undervalued companies with the potential for significant performance improvement through strategic changes.
• Industry benchmarking: They compare a company’s performance to industry leaders, seeking out potential acquirers or restructuring opportunities that could unlock hidden value. This benchmarking exercise allows them to identify companies that may be underperforming relative to their peers.
• Corporate governance scrutiny: Activist investors assess the effectiveness of the board of directors and management team, identifying areas where leadership may be hindering shareholder value creation. They may scrutinize aspects such as board composition, executive compensation, and strategic decision-making processes.

Once a target is identified, activist investors have a range of tools at their disposal to advocate for change and influence M&A strategy:

• Shareholder engagement: They engage in constructive dialogue with the company’s board and management, proposing strategic changes and restructuring plans that aim to unlock shareholder value. This collaborative approach can lead to mutually beneficial outcomes for both the activist investor and the company.
• Proxy contests: They may challenge the existing board composition by nominating their own candidates, aiming to gain greater influence over company decisions, including those related to M&A activity. This tactic can be a powerful tool for forcing companies to consider alternative strategies.
• Public campaigns: Activist investors leverage media relations to raise awareness of their concerns and garner support from other shareholders, potentially pressuring management to consider their proposals regarding M&A strategy. By bringing public attention to their cause, they can create a groundswell of support for their agenda.

How do Activist Investors impact M&A valuations?

Activist investors are leaving their mark on the world of M&A. Here’s how their involvement can change the game:

• Bidding wars: Activist campaigns can spark bidding wars between acquirers, driving up the target company’s price. The activist spotlight exposes the target’s potential, attracting new suitors. Pressure on the target’s board to maximize shareholder value makes them more receptive to offers. Strategic bidders may pay a premium to win the deal.
• Strategic focus: Activist pressure can push companies towards M&A that creates long-term value. This could involve strategic acquisitions for synergies and growth, divestitures of underperforming assets, or improved corporate governance for better value creation. Activist involvement ensures M&A decisions are driven by long-term strategy, not short-term gains.
• Data-driven approach: Activist investors bring strong financial analysis skills to the table. They scrutinize financials, benchmark against peers, and consider future growth potential. This ensures a more rigorous valuation of the target company, benefiting both the target and the acquirer. Fairer deals are reached based on a clear understanding of the target’s true value.

The future of activist investors in M&A is bright. Expect specialization and collaboration to lead to laser-focused campaigns. ESG will become a core focus, pushing companies towards sustainable M&A strategies. Technological advancements will empower them with sharper insights, while regulatory adaptations will be met with strategic adjustments. Finally, a shared focus on long-term value creation could lead to more collaboration with companies, benefiting all stakeholders.

If you need any assistance with M&A valuation, due diligence and more, choose MS as we can help you to make the whole process seamless and hassle-free.